For adult children deciding between a home care agency and a private caregiver, this guide breaks down the real cost gap, what the agency markup buys, and what private hire requires — including payroll, taxes, insurance, and backup planning — so you can make an informed choice that balances savings with safety and peace of mind.
A printable version of this guide is available. Use your browser's print function (Ctrl+P / ⌘P) to save or print.
When you hire a home care agency, the rate you see on the invoice is not what the caregiver takes home. That gap — often $10 to $20 per hour — is the central tension in the agency-versus-private decision.
In a typical arrangement, a home care agency charges the family $35 to $45 per hour while paying the caregiver $14 to $20 per hour. The caregiver who works directly for a family, by contrast, typically earns about $25 per hour — meaning the caregiver takes home more, and the family often pays less overall. Data from Alula, based on a Charlottesville, Virginia case study, illustrates this dynamic clearly: agency rates of $35–$45/hr versus a private caregiver rate of $25/hr.
To put this in perspective, the Bureau of Labor Statistics reports a 2024 national median wage of $16.78 per hour for home health and personal care aides. The agency markup — roughly 20% to 30% above what the caregiver earns — covers real costs, but it also means families are paying a significant premium for the infrastructure behind the caregiver.
The most common home care schedule is approximately 20 nonsleeping hours per week. At this level of care, the cost difference between an agency and a private caregiver becomes substantial — typically $400 to $1,200 per month.
| Cost Component | Agency Care | Private Caregiver (All-In) |
|---|---|---|
| Hourly rate charged to family | $35–$45/hr | ~$25/hr |
| Monthly cost (20 hrs/week) | $2,800–$3,600/mo | ~$2,000/mo (base wages) |
| Payroll service ($50–$75/mo) | Included | +$50–$75/mo |
| Workers' comp insurance (~$40/mo) | Included | +~$40/mo |
| Background check ($50–$100 one-time) | Included | +$50–$100 (one-time) |
| Total monthly cost (20 hrs/week) | $2,800–$3,600/mo | ~$2,400/mo |
| Monthly savings with private hire | — | $400–$1,200/mo |
Comments
Join the discussion with an anonymous comment.